Liberty Investor Alert Personal Finance Retirement Planning


  • Economy & Politics
  • Investing
  • Personal Finance
  • Related Posts

    Hostages Taken In Paris Suburb Post Office, AFP Reports
    Scammers Are Cashing In On Your Ebola Fears
    The Next Obamacare Crisis
    A First: Judge Rules NSA Data Collection Likely Unconstitutional
    Now This Is Money For The Grandkids
    Learning From ‘Tony Soprano’
    Rural Riches
    Fed Decision Means More Volatility
    Revisiting The Safe Withdrawal Rate
    Waiting For Bernanke
    Exiting 401(k)s: Facts And Scandal
    Down Market Is Right-Side Up Again
    One Simple Thing You Can Do To Increase Your Returns Dramatically
    What To Do Now That The Great Rotation Has Begun
    The Bull Within The Bear

    Comparing Annuities To Bonds

    Can you build a bond portfolio that does a better job of providing secure retirement income than an immediate annuity?

    Economists and many financial advisers believe some portion of a retiree’s portfolio should be placed in immediate annuities. These are annuities that pay a regular income for life or for the joint life of the owner and a spouse. Immediate annuity payments can be either fixed or inflation-adjusted.

    Only a small portion of retirees follows this advice. Four reasons generally are given for the reluctance to buy annuities. The most frequent reason is that people don’t want to relinquish control of part of their nest eggs. Related to that is that the annuity is inflexible; the owner often can’t withdraw additional income in a year when it’s needed. Another reason: Many people don’t want to forego the potential to earn higher returns should a new bull market emerge. Finally, with an immediate annuity there’s nothing left for your heirs.

    These are reasons not to put your entire nest egg into an immediate annuity. But they shouldn’t override the reasons to include an immediate annuity as some portion of your retirement assets. Most of us need to have a secure floor on our income for life and to transfer the risks of a long life and poor returns to the insurer.

    Can you avoid these risks by purchasing long-term bonds instead of an annuity? The question is addressed in a study by Michael Edesess that was published recently on

    Bonds initially appear to have the upper hand, because you won’t be paying the costs embedded in an annuity. Edesess estimates that at recent prices a fixed annuity has an expected return of 1.5 percent, while an inflation-adjusted annuity’s expected return is -1.9 percent. Though bonds have extremely low yields now, the yields on long-term bonds are higher than expected returns on annuities. But only the long-term bonds yields are competitive with annuities. The traditional strategy of laddering bonds of different maturities offers expected returns well below those on annuities right now, according to Edesess.

    To compare owning bonds to immediate annuities, Edesess sought to answer the question: What would happen if a person were to buy a 30-year Treasury bond and spend the interest, plus sell the bond piecemeal to generate annual income equal to the annuity payouts? How does that compare with using the same amount of money to purchase an annuity?

    The results would be comparable over 30 years if interest rates were stable. Comparing a fixed annuity to a nominal Treasury bond, after 30 years there would be less than a year’s income left in the Treasury bond. Comparing a 30-year Treasury Inflation-Protected Security (TIPS) to an inflation-indexed annuity, the TIPS lasts only 27 years. So for a 65-year-old the nominal Treasury would last to age 95 and the TIPS would last to age 92. If you don’t think there’s much of a risk of living past 95, the Treasury bond alternative looks feasible.

    The picture changes, however, when interest rates rise over the years. That’s because the value of the bond will fall when rates rise, so more of the bond will have to be sold each year to generate the same income. When yields rise from a recent .4 percent to .9 percent on the TIPS over the next 10 years, the TIPS bond lasts only 25 years. If the yields rise only 1 percentage point, the bond lasts only 23 years. If the rate on the nominal bond rises 1 percentage point, the bond lasts only 25 years. If the nominal bond yield rises 2 percentage points (which still would leave the yield below the 40-year average), the bond lasts only 21 years.

    Another factor to consider is income taxes. When the assets that would purchase either the annuity or bond are held in an individual retirement account, there aren’t tax differences. The distributions from the IRA will be taxed as ordinary income unless they represent after-tax contributions.

    But there are differences outside the IRA. In a taxable account, part of each annuity payment will be tax-free until you’ve recovered the initial investment in the annuity, which will occur when you reach life expectancy. One estimate is that about 75 percent of the annuity distributions will be non-taxable until life expectancy is reached. After that, all the distributions are fully taxable. For bonds, the interest will be taxed as ordinary income, and sales of the bond are tax-free unless interest rates fall and the bond is sold for more than its cost. But in the early years, more of the payout will be interest, so Edesess believes there will be less tax deferral with the bond. But the tax-free portion of those payouts will grow over time.

    The bottom line is you aren’t likely to be able to duplicate the safety and certainty of an immediate annuity’s guaranteed income. If market yields increase, you might be able over time to increase the return from bonds above what you’d receive from an annuity. But to do that you have to take the risk that things don’t turn out well and you lose money. To earn secure, guaranteed lifetime income, it’s tough to beat an immediate annuity. For that security you give up some flexibility and control of your assets plus the potential of leaving a legacy to the next generation.

    Bob Carlson is editor of the monthly newsletter and web site, Retirement Watch. Carlson is Chairman of the Board of Trustees of the Fairfax County Employees' Retirement System, which has over $3 billion in assets, and was a member of the Board of Trustees of the Virginia Retirement System, which oversaw $42 billion in assets, from 2001-2005. He was appointed to the Virginia Retirement System Deferred Compensation Plans Advisory Committee in 2011. His latest book is Personal Finance for Seniors for Dummies, published by John Wiley & Co. in 2010 (with Eric Tyson). Previous books include Invest Like a Fox... Not Like a Hedgehog, published by John Wiley & Co. in 2007, and The New Rules of Retirement, as published by John Wiley & Co. in the fall of 2004. He has written numerous other books and reports, including Tax Wise Money Strategies, Retirement Tax Guide, How to Slash Your Mutual Fund Taxes, Bob Carlson's Estate Planning Files, and 199 Loopholes That Survived tax Reform. He also has been interviewed by or quoted in numerous publications, including The Wall Street Journal, Reader's Digest, Barron's, AARP Bulletin, Money, Worth, Kiplinger's Personal Finance, the Washington Post, and many others. He has appeared on national television and on a number of radio programs. He is past editor of Tax Wise Money. Carlson is an attorney and passed the CPA Exam. He received his J.D. and an M.S. (Accounting) from the University of Virginia and received his B.S. (Financial Management) from Clemson University. He also is an instrument rated private pilot. He is listed in several recent editions of Who's Who in America and Who's Who in the World.

    | All posts from Bob Carlson

    Discuss this Story:

    Comment Policy: We encourage open discussion. Comments including racist statements, profanity, name calling or spam will be removed at our discretion. We use filters for spam protection. If your comment does not appear it is likely because it violates the policy.

    Students Should Look To Two-Year And Certificate Programs In Lieu Of Traditional Degrees
    Staying In The 15 Percent (Or Lower) Tax Bracket
    This Near Monopoly Can Still Double The Size Of Its Business
    Yield Deals Right Now
    High Taxes Mean Less Revenue For Some States
    Beware Of This ‘Dead Money’ Investment
    We’re No. 11! We’re No. 11!
    Putting Power In Your Power Of Attorney
    Mises Institute:That Savings Glut vs. Those Low Interest Rates
    Lessons From ‘Pawn Stars’
    Getting The Masses Online: Mark Zuckerberg’s Quaint Plan
    The New Focus Of Estate Planning
    The Adults Are Back In Charge
    Time For A Few Tech Titans To Tumble?
    Covering Long-Term Care Costs With Annuities
    Tune In Now For Three Great Deals
    2 Unique Financial Stocks
    Your Estate-Planning Agenda
    A Bigger Market Means Bigger Dividends
    2 Sentimental Stocks To Sell Now
    To Avoid Probate Or Not?
    You’re Going To Make Some Money From The New EPA Chief
    3 Top Energy Income Stocks
    Minimizing Taxes On Annuity Payouts
    Exploding Myths About Long-Term Care
    The Pipes Are Calling
    The Biggest Lie About Spiking Interest Rates
    Tips For Small Cap Biotech Investing
    A Common-Sense Answer To The Biggest Retirement Worry
    Get Off The Train And Pipe In The Profits
    Read more from Liberty Investor Alert...

    Liberty Investor Digest

    Get today's most important
    financial headlines all in
    one place by email!



    Sign Up For Liberty Investor Digest™!

    Get Liberty Investor Digest FREE By Email!

    Input your name and email address in the fields below and get today's most important financial headlines sent straight to you inbox!

    Privacy PolicyYou can opt-out at any time. We protect your information like a mother hen. We will not sell or rent your email address to anyone for any reason.